I get a lot of questions and concerns every day about “PMI” or whether or not we (as customer’s) have to pay mortgage insurance. Many customer’s have told me in the past that they simply will not have a mortgage with “PMI” because they do not believe in it and that’s all there is to it. I think it’s important to understand what it is, why it was created, what it does for you, and when you should have it and when you shouldn’t. I’m going to try to answer some of the basic questions now.
What is Mortgage Insurance?
Let’s start by talking about what it is not. It is not “Hazard Insurance or Homeowner’s Insurance”. These insurances are required to get a mortgage, but they also protect you in case there was something that damaged your home. Mortgage insurance is a premium that is paid each month to your mortgage company to insure them in case you were to stop paying. Essentially, you are paying this monthly premium so that your lender is protected. Most times, the insurance will stay on for five years or when the loan reaches 78% of the appraised value.
On the surface, this sounds ridiculous. Why would i pay an insurance premium so that someone else is protected. The theory is that, without this insurance, the ability to get a mortgage without a ton of money down and without paying exorbitant interest rates would be slim. Mortgage lenders simply would not offer the kinds of loans that would be needed to get your average consumer into a home. That point can be debated but is best left for another post. For now, that is the current theory.
What kinds of loans have Mortgage Insurance.
There are two types of loans that have premiums on them that are referenced as mortgage insurance premiums. There are other loans on the market that have fees associated with them that could be arguably construed as insurance premiums but we will leave those out for purposes of keeping this post fairly short. The two types of loans that i will be talking about are Conventional and FHA.
Let us start with Conventional Loans. Conventional Loans are loans that are not insured or guaranteed by the government. The two types of conventional loans are conforming and non-conforming. The type of conventional loan that is going to have mortgage insurance is a conforming conventional loan. In a nutshell, if you are going to do a conventional loan and do not plan on putting at least 20% down, you are going to have mortgage insurance on the loan that will be paid monthly in addition to what you pay in principal and interest. The amount of this insurance ranges and is based on how much money you are putting down, your credit score, and whether or not the loan you are doing is a fixed or adjustable rate. If you are putting 20% or more down, you will not have mortgage insurance on a conventional loan.
The second type of loan with mortgage insurance is an FHA loan. The amount of insurance required will vary, however FHA loans will always have some sort of mortgage insurance on them. FHA loans will have insurance in two places. The first part is an up-front insurance. This is not something you pay out-of-pocket for as a customer but will be rolled into the loan amount. Currently, that up-front premium is 1% of the loan amount. This up-front insurance is the same on every FHA Loan. The second part is the monthly premium. The amount of the required monthly insurance varies and is tied to the term of the loan.
Should i be ok with Mortgage Insurance?
There are a lot of times in my profession that i can easily get caught up in crossing the line between being a mortgage advisor and an overall financial advisor. I am very careful not to overstep here. However, with that said, the best thing i can advise on is to know what your goals for the property are and understand the market. If your goal is to be in the home for a very short amount of time, i would advise strongly to consider the implications of dropping a whole bunch of cash into a property to simply avoid an insurance premium when your goal is to not stay there very long anyway. The risk vs. reward equation in that scenario needs to be evaluated. Personally, i would consider holding on to my cash. On the other hand, if this property is the one that you plan on staying in for a long time, the cash infusion may be worth it to reduce the total cost of financing on the home and get rid of the insurance. This can all be evaluated very easily be looking at the estimated time in the property and comparing it to an amortization schedule.
How do you “get out” of paying mortgage insurance?
Lastly, i want to talk a little about some of the ways you can “avoid” paying mortgage insurance. I put “avoid” in quotes because, at the end of the day, if you are doing an FHA loan or a Conventional Loan over 80%, you are going to incur additional cost.
The first and most popular way to avoid mortgage insurance is to do what’s called a piggyback loan. This is when you buy a home using two mortgages at the same time….a first mortgage and a second mortgage. The most common type nowadays is what’s called an 80/10/10. This is where the mortgage company does a first mortgage (conventional) at 80%, the customer puts down 10%, and a second mortgage is simultaneously taken out at closing for the last 10%. In this case, the first mortgage would not have MI. However, there are two drawback to this scenario.
The first one is that the lender who does this loan simultaneously with the second mortgage often times prices the 80% loan a little higher than normal because they see additional risk with the customer taking out a second mortgage at the same time as their first. For example, instead of you getting a 4.25% rate, you get a 4.5% rate. Yeah, you don’t have MI on that 4.5%, but the long-term cost of that loan probably just went higher than if you had mortgage insurance.
The second drawback is that now you have a second mortgage on the property. This doesn’t sound like a big deal since you would have owed that money anyway. However, these second mortgages that are used in 80/10/10 scenarious are most often interest only equity lines with variable rates. If you are not careful, you can end up with an equity line that doesn’t seem to ever go away with regard to the balance and the rate can go up on you.
The two other ways that you can avoid paying for mortgage insurance (other than just putting 20% down) is to go with a non-conforming loan or to elect “lender paid” insurance. The first option, a non-conforming loan, is when you take out a loan that is not eligible to be sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. These would typically be done with a lender that holds all of their loans and does not plan to sell them. Here’s the deal….these lenders are not stupid. They understand that doing a loan without 20% down is risky just like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac do. Most times, you will see that the interest rates with these companies are a quarter to 1/2% higher…..there goes your savings. The other option, which often times customer’s do not know about, is for the lender to pay it. This is called “lender paid insurance”. All that is happening in this scenario is the lender is increasing the interest rate offered to make more money and pay the insurance on behalf of the customer. To this day, i have not seen an instance where this makes sense in the long run.
To summarize, the key is to know your plans for the property and to compare amortization for the time you plan on spending their. Please contact me with any questions on this.